In these civil appeals, the State of Uttarakhand challenged the common judgment and order dated April 15, 2010 passed by the High Court of Uttarakhand, which had struck down Regulation 7(2) of the Uttarakhand Public Service Commission (Conditions of Service) Regulations, 2004 as ultra vires Article 14 read with Article 39(d) of the Constitution for violating the principle of “equal pay for equal work”. The High Court had invalidated the deduction of service pension from the basic pay of retired government servants appointed as the Chairman or Members of the Uttarakhand Public Service Commission (PSC).
The Supreme Court allowed the State’s appeals and set aside the High Court’s judgment, holding that Regulation 7(2) is constitutionally valid and legally sound. The Court clarified that withholding a portion of a pension during the active tenure of a constitutional post (applying the “pay minus pension” norm) does not amount to a permanent withdrawal of pension, nor does it violate the doctrine of “equal pay for equal work”. Furthermore, the Court emphasized that appointees who accept a post with open eyes and full knowledge of applicable service rules are estopped by the principle of acquiescence from challenging those conditions later.
1. Factual Matrix & High Court Proceedings
- Appointments: Respondent No. 1 in the lead appeal, Lt. Gen. (Retd.) M.C. Bhandari, retired from the Indian Army and was appointed Chairman of the Uttarakhand PSC on November 3, 2006. Respondent No. 1 in the second appeal, Sohan Lal, took voluntary retirement from the State PCS and was appointed a Member of the Uttarakhand PSC on July 22, 2006.
- Salary Fixation & Deductions: In accordance with Regulation 7(1) read with Regulation 7(2) of the Uttarakhand Public Service Commission Regulations, 2004, their basic pay was fixed, but their previously drawn service pensions were deducted from their monthly salaries, and kept in abeyance.
- The High Court’s Ruling: The High Court allowed the writ petitions, declaring Regulation 7(2) ultra vires Articles 14 and 39(d) on the ground that reducing salary by the pension amount violated “equal pay for equal work,” as duties and responsibilities remained identical regardless of past service.
2. Key Legal & Constitutional Findings by the Supreme Court
- Validity of “Pay Minus Pension” (Regulation 7(2)):
- Article 318 of the Constitution empowers the Governor to determine the conditions of service of members of a State Public Service Commission.
- Regulation 7(2) explicitly provides that if a Chairman or Member is a retired government servant, the Governor may determine whether their service pension shall be held in abeyance or if their basic pay shall be reduced by an amount not exceeding such pension.
- Nature of Pension Abeyance vs. Deprivation:
- The Court noted that withholding the pension amount during the tenure of the Chairman or Member does not mean the pension is permanently forfeited or withdrawn.
- Once their tenure on the Commission concludes, the embargo is lifted, and their entitlement to the full pension revives. This is consistent with precedents such as Gurmesh Prakash Bishnoi v. State of Haryana (1998).
- Misapplication of “Equal Pay for Equal Work”:
- The High Court fundamentally misdirected itself by invoking the doctrine of “equal pay for equal work”. Adding unadjusted pensions on top of the fixed constitutional salary would lead to absurd financial outcomes, wherein total emoluments exceed the highest constitutional salary caps.
- Duly Issued Office Memorandum:
- An Office Memorandum dated September 16, 2008 was validly issued reflecting the Governor’s formal determination under Regulation 7(2). The contention that this operated with illegal retrospectivity was rejected, as the Regulations were already in force at the time of appointment.
3. Doctrine of Estoppel and Acquiescence
- Knowledge and Acceptance: Both respondents accepted their respective appointments in 2006 with full knowledge of the currency and applicability of the 2004 Regulations.
- “Playing the Game”: Re-applying the settled principle that a candidate or employee who participates in a process or accepts an appointment cannot later challenge its rules and service conditions after enjoying its benefits, the Court held that the respondents were legally estopped from disputing Regulation 7(2) at the fag end of their tenure.
4. Final Orders
- The common judgment and order of the High Court dated April 15, 2010 are set aside.
- The civil appeals filed by the State of Uttarakhand are allowed.
2026 INSC 1194
State of Uttarakhand thr. Chief Secretary and Others v. M.C. Bhandari and Another (D.O.J. 04.11.2026)
Loading Viewer...






