The Supreme Court heard an appeal filed by Akanksha Devi, who had successfully cleared the Document Verification, Physical Standard Test, and written evaluations for the post of Constable Civil Police under the U.P. Police Constable Civil Direct Recruitment, 2023. However, she was disqualified by the medical board and division medical board on the ground of having a squint eye. Disputing this finding based on independent medical opinions, she approached the High Court, which dismissed her plea due to the conclusion of the selection process. Noting similar past practice, the Supreme Court directed an independent evaluation by King George’s Medical University (KGMU), Lucknow. Upon receiving KGMU’s expert medical report, the Supreme Court set aside the High Court’s order, allowed the appeal, and directed the authorities to issue an appointment letter, clarifying that she would not claim seniority over already appointed candidates.
1. Factual Matrix & Medical Disqualification
- Selection Process Cleared: The appellant applied for the post of Constable Civil Police under the U.P. Police Constable Civil Direct Recruitment, 2023, successfully passing the document verification and physical standard tests.
- Medical Rejection: During the medical examination on April 22, 2025, and subsequent re-examination by the Division Medical Board on April 25, 2025, she was declared medically unfit due to an alleged eye defect (squint eye).
- Independent Consultations: Challenging the board’s findings, she consulted independent experts, including the Dean of the Eye Department at GSVM Medical College and a consultant eye surgeon at UHM District Hospital, who found her vision and colour perception normal. Her representation and subsequent High Court petition were both dismissed.
2. Supreme Court’s Intervention & Expert Evaluation
- KGMU Medical Board Reference: Following its earlier precedent, the Supreme Court directed the appellant to appear before a specially constituted medical board comprising ophthalmology experts at King George’s Medical University (KGMU), Lucknow.
- KGMU Medical Report: The KGMU report submitted on October 16, 2026, confirmed that her vision (best corrected 6/6), near vision, pupillary reaction, ocular movements, and fundus were within normal limits, while noting mild intermittent exophoria/exotropia with good control and present stereopsis.
3. Final Ruling and Directions
- Setting Aside High Court Order: The Supreme Court held that the appellant was wrongfully deprived of her legitimate right to public employment after successfully clearing all selection tests.
- Appointment Ordered: The impugned order of the High Court was set aside, and the appeal was allowed.
- Conditions of Appointment: The respondents were directed to issue an order of appointment/call letter to the appellant, subject to her being otherwise entitled, with the specific condition that she shall not claim seniority over candidates already appointed.
2026 INSC 1184
Akanksha Devi v. State of U.P. & Ors. (D.O.J. 02.11.2026)
Loading Viewer...






