This landmark decision by a Seven-Judge Bench of the Supreme Court of India resolves a nearly three-decade-old reference regarding the legislative competence of State Legislatures under Entry 54 of List II of the Seventh Schedule to the Constitution. The core legal question was whether a State could validly levy an additional tax, surcharge, or cess calculated as a percentage of the sales tax payable by a dealer (rather than directly on their turnover), or whether such an imposition amounted to an unconstitutional “tax on tax” or a tax on the dealer’s income.
The Court unanimously held that the reference was rendered infructuous/academic in light of subsequent constitutional and legal developments—notably the Nine-Judge Bench ruling in Mineral Area Development Authority (MADA) v. SAIL (2024). Reaffirming the Five-Judge Constitution Bench precedent in S. Kodar v. State of Kerala (1974), the Court ruled that an additional tax or surcharge calculated on sales tax payable is in substance an enhancement of the rate of sales tax on the aggregate sales of a dealer. It remains fully valid under Entry 54 of List II as a tax on the sale or purchase of goods, and does not constitute an invalid tax on income or a “tax on tax”.
- Background & Scope of Issues
- The Surcharge Structure: The primary lead appeal arose out of Section 5-A of the Orissa Sales Tax Act, 1947, which levied a 10% surcharge on the total sales tax payable by dealers whose gross turnover exceeded ₹10 lakhs. Similar provisions under the Punjab General Sales Tax Act, 1948 (Section 5(1-C) and Section 30-AA) were also challenged.
- The Assessees’ Contention: Dealers argued that a surcharge computed on the tax payable (rather than directly on turnover) was a “tax on tax” or a levy on the dealer’s income/fiscal burden, exceeding State competence under Entry 54 of List II.
- Origin of Reference: The reference originated in 1998 due to a perceived conflict between Hoechst Pharmaceuticals Ltd. v. State of Bihar (1983) and the Seven-Judge Bench decision in India Cement Ltd. v. State of Tamil Nadu (1990), which held a local cess on royalty to be an invalid “cess on royalty/tax on tax”.
- Key Legal & Constitutional Findings
- Subject of Tax vs. Measure of Tax: The Court highlighted the settled distinction between the taxable event (subject of tax) and the yardstick for quantification (measure of tax). A surcharge of 10% on a 10% sales tax is arithmetically equivalent to a 1% additional tax on turnover. The mode of computation does not alter the essential character of the levy as a tax on the sale or purchase of goods.
- Not a Tax on Income: The surcharge escalates with turnover volume, not profit. It remains payable even if a dealer incurs a loss, ensuring it cannot be characterized as an income tax. Furthermore, a tax does not lose its character as a sales tax merely because a dealer is statutorily prohibited from passing the burden on to consumers.
- Resolution of Conflict (India Cement & MADA):
- The perceived conflict with India Cement (1990) was cleared by the Nine-Judge Bench in MADA v. SAIL (2024), which overruled India Cement to the extent it held that “royalty is a tax”.
- Because royalty is a contractual consideration and not a tax, the premise that India Cement disallowed a “tax on tax” is legally non-existent.
- Continued Authority of S. Kodar: The Five-Judge Bench decision in S. Kodar v. State of Kerala (1974) remains solid, binding precedent. It conclusively establishes that additional sales tax/surcharge based on tax payable is a valid enhancement of sales tax rates.
- Altered Constitutional Landscape: Following the 101st Constitutional Amendment Act (2016) introducing the Goods and Services Tax (GST) regime and modifying Entry 54 of List II, the legacy sales tax surcharges relate exclusively to past assessment periods.
- Directions & Segregation of Residual Matters
- Reference Answered: The reference is answered as infructuous/academic. The legislative competence of States to impose sales tax surcharges is governed by S. Kodar.
- Segregation of Punjab Social Security Cess: The challenges to the Punjab Social Security Act, 2000 (concerning Article 266 Consolidated Fund compliance) are delinked/segregated to be decided separately by a Division Bench.
- Exempted Units (Section 30-AA of Punjab Act): Specific statutory questions regarding whether exempted industrial units can be made liable to pay surcharge under Section 30-AA of the Punjab Act are left open for determination on individual merits by regular Benches.
- Disposal of Appeals: The Registry was directed to list individual appeals before appropriate regular Benches for final disposal in accordance with the law laid down in S. Kodar.
2026 INSC 1192
Arjun Flour Mills v. The State of Odisha Finance Department Secretary & Ors. (with connected appeals) (D.O.J. 04.11.2026)
Loading Viewer...






