This criminal appeal was filed by a District Judge from the Rajasthan Judicial Services seeking the expungement of adverse remarks and strictures passed against her by a learned Single Judge of the High Court of Rajasthan while dismissing an application for suspension of sentence. While adjudicating the bail matter arising out of a POCSO trial, the High Court criticized the appellant for using a “cut, copy and paste” methodology, alleging that she had failed to dictate the entire judgment and merely signed a draft prepared by her stenographer due to overlapping evidence between two related trials. The High Court directed that the order be made a part of her Annual Confidential Report (ACR) and that she undergo training at the judicial academy.
- Context of the Error: The appellant conducted two parallel trials arising out of the same FIR—one against an adult co-accused and another against a Child in Conflict with Law (CNCL)—mandated by the statutory bar against joint proceedings. Due to intricately intermingled facts, identical witnesses, limited court resources, and the absence of her regular stenographer on leave, minor overlapping textual and numerical details inadvertently crept into the judgment as bona fide typographical errors that did not affect the final outcome.
- Violation of Natural Justice: The Supreme Court reiterated that High Courts must not record disparaging remarks against the personal conduct or caliber of judicial officers on the judicial side without first affording them an opportunity to present their explanation.
- Supervisory Role of High Courts: Emphasizing quotes from Alexander Pope and ancient jurisprudence regarding human fallibility and forgiveness (Uttama Kshama / Kshama Virasya Bhushanam), the Court observed that the supervisory jurisdiction of High Courts under Article 227 of the Constitution must be exercised to guide, strengthen, and nurture the district judiciary with magnanimity rather than crushing judicial morale.
- Proper Procedure for Addressing Grievances: The Court reiterated that if a High Court finds technical flaws or concerns regarding a judgment or the performance of a presiding officer, the appropriate recourse is to record observations in a remark slip for consideration by the Chief Justice on the administrative side, rather than issuing harsh judicial strictures that can irreparably damage a judicial officer’s career.
- Final Relief: Paragraphs 9, 10, 11, 17, and 18 of the High Court’s impugned order—including the ACR entry and training directives—were completely expunged and set aside.
2026 INSC 1188
In Re: XXX, A Judicial Officer in the District Judge Cadre of Rajasthan Judicial Services v. High Court of Judicature for Rajasthan (D.O.J. 02.11.2026)
Loading Viewer...






