The Supreme Court heard cross-appeals arising from a Madras High Court Division Bench judgment that had condoned a 423-day delay by the fourth defendant in filing an application to set aside an ex parte decree, while imposing a condition to pay ₹75,00,000 directly to the plaintiff company. While the fourth defendant contested the imposition and direct payment of this amount, the plaintiff company challenged the condonation of delay itself. The Supreme Court upheld the discretion exercised by the High Court in condoning the delay to allow a trial on merits, but modified the financial condition—holding that the ₹75,00,000 should be deposited with the High Court in an interest-bearing fixed deposit to abide by the final outcome of the proceedings rather than being disbursed immediately to the plaintiff.
1. Background and Factual Matrix
- The Original Suit: Integrated Finance Company Ltd. filed a civil suit (CS No. 530 of 2011) to recover ₹21,88,11,451.96 under various hire purchase and lease agreements against a partnership firm and its partners (defendant nos. 1 to 4).
- Ex Parte Decree: Due to non-appearance, defendant nos. 1, 2, and 4 were set ex parte on August 27, 2021, and the Single Judge decreed the suit on November 15, 2021.
- Application to Set Aside: The fourth defendant filed an application on February 15, 2023 (along with a delay condonation application for 423 days), claiming he was not served summons and was unaware of the proceedings.
- Single Judge vs. Division Bench: The Single Judge dismissed the delay application due to a lack of bona fides. However, the Division Bench condoned the delay but conditioned it on the fourth defendant paying ₹75,00,000 to the plaintiff for disbursement to depositors. Both parties appealed this decision to the Supreme Court.
2. Key Observations of the Supreme Court
- Condonation of Delay: The Supreme Court declined to interfere with the Division Bench’s discretion in condoning the 423-day delay. It emphasized that shutting out a party from contesting substantial proceedings on merits is undesirable unless the delay is wholly arbitrary or irrational.
- Modification of Financial Terms: While requiring the deposit of ₹75,00,000 as a condition for condoning delay was deemed reasonable, directing its immediate payout to the plaintiff was unwarranted before the ex parte decree is even set aside or contested.
- Protection of Interests: The Court noted that the deposited money should remain secure to safeguard both parties’ interests pending the final outcome.
3. Final Directions
- Delay Condonation Maintained: The Division Bench’s order condoning the 423-day delay and permitting the fourth defendant to file a written statement was left undisturbed.
- Modification of Payment Condition: The direction instructing the fourth defendant to pay ₹75,00,000 directly to the plaintiff was modified. Instead, the amount deposited pursuant to the Supreme Court’s interim order dated September 10, 2024, is ordered to remain in deposit with the High Court in an interest-bearing fixed deposit, subject to the final outcome of the proceedings.
- Uninfluenced Merits: The application to set aside the ex parte decree will be considered by the Single Judge independently on its own merits, uninfluenced by prior observations from the High Court or Supreme Court.
- Disposal: Both civil appeals were disposed of with no order as to costs.
2026 INSC 1182: Hiroo Hotchand Advani v. Integrated Finance Company Limited and Others (with Civil Appeal No. of 2026 @ SLP (C) No. 27307 of 2024) (D.O.J. 28.10.2026)
Loading Viewer...






