The High Court of Himachal Pradesh dismissed a senior employee’s writ petition seeking stepping up of pay at par with his junior, holding that the pay disparity resulted from the voluntary options exercised by the employees rather than any pay anomaly. The Court further found that stepping up was barred under Rule 9(2) of the H.P. Civil Services (Revised Pay) Rules, 2022 and that the claim suffered from unexplained delay and laches.
- Factual Background & Pay Disparity: The petitioner and his junior, Shri Bal Kishan, were both promoted as Kanungo on 31.05.2010 and subsequently promoted as Naib Tehsildar in June 2016 and Tehsildar in March 2022. In December 2025, the petitioner’s monthly basic pay was Rs. 65,800 compared to Shri Bal Kishan’s Rs. 69,800.
- Promotion Option & Delay: Contrary to the petitioner’s claim that he was denied an option upon promotion to Kanungo on 31.05.2010, he exercised an option on 29.06.2010 for pay fixation from the date of joining (15.06.2010), whereas Shri Bal Kishan opted for fixation after accrual of his next increment in the feeder post on 01.01.2011. Despite drawing lower pay since then without protest, the petitioner represented in September 2019 (rejected on 30.06.2020) and filed the writ petition in April 2026, making the claim barred by delay and laches.
- Revised Pay Rules, 2022 & Rule 9(2): For pay revision under the H.P. Civil Services (Revised Pay) Rules, 2022 (notified on 03.01.2022 and effective from 01.01.2016), the petitioner opted on 31.01.2022 for a 2.59 factor, while Shri Bal Kishan opted on 24.02.2022 for a 15% enhancement. Under Rule 9(2)(i), stepping up is inadmissible where a pay difference arises from exercising pay fixation options on revision by a different factor.
- Distinguishing Precedents & Parity: The Court held that Pyar Chand Sharma and related precedents were distinguishable because the disparity here flowed from valid, voluntary options under applicable rules rather than an anomaly, illegality, or arbitrariness. Seniority alone does not entitle a senior employee to automatic or mechanical pay parity when pay differences stem from permissible choices under the rules.
- Decision: Finding no merit in the petition, the Court dismissed it along with any pending miscellaneous applications.
STPL (Web) 2026 HP 751
Subhash Kumar vs. The Additional Chief Secretary (Revenue) and Ors. (D.O.J. 06.10.2026)
Loading Viewer...






