This judgment by the Supreme Court of India addresses a civil appeal filed against the judgment of the Rajasthan High Court, which had set aside a trial court decree granting compensation to an electrocution victim. The appellant, who was a minor at the time of the incident, suffered severe burn injuries and the amputation of her right hand after coming into contact with a sagging 11 KV electricity transmission line. While the trial court awarded compensation based on clear oral and medical evidence establishing the power utility’s negligence, the High Court reversed the decision, citing mere suspicion and minor inconsistencies. The Supreme Court allowed the appeal, heavily criticizing the High Court for basing its decision on personal conjecture and speculation rather than the established rules of evidence in civil trials, thereby restoring the trial court’s award of compensation.
- Factual Background: The appellant, a minor on the date of the incident (July 15, 2011), sustained severe burn injuries due to a sagging 11 KV electric transmission line hanging 3-4 feet above the ground in her village. Her injuries were so severe that after receiving initial medical care, her right hand had to be amputated at Agra, rendering her permanently handicapped.
- Trial Court Proceedings: Civil Case No. 02 of 2015 was instituted, leading the trial court to rule in favor of the appellant and direct the electricity distribution company (JVVNL) to pay Rs. 8,70,000 as compensation with 6% interest. The trial court found that the plaintiff’s witnesses and medical records established the negligence of the respondents in maintaining the transmission lines.
- High Court Interference: In an appeal filed by JVVNL, the High Court reversed the trial court’s decree, holding that the incident was “unbelievable” and “suspicious” due to delayed reporting to the police and minor contradictions among witnesses.
- Supreme Court’s Legal Analysis:
- Standard of Proof in Civil Cases: The Supreme Court reiterated that civil cases are decided on the principle of preponderance of probability, which requires a higher degree of possibility rather than proof beyond a reasonable doubt.
- Misdirected Appellate Review: The Apex Court held that the High Court committed a grave error in law by overturning a well-considered trial court judgment based on mere ipse dixit (personal assertion) and suspicion, without providing concrete grounds that the witnesses were untruthful.
- Strict Liability: The Court emphasized that power distribution companies owe a duty of care, and cases involving hazards from live electricity transmission lines attract the principle of strict liability when the incident is duly established by evidence.
- Final Decision: The Supreme Court set aside the High Court’s order dated May 10, 2024, and fully restored the judgment and decree passed by the trial court in Civil Case No. 02 of 2015.
2026 INSC 1216
Rekha v. Jaipur Vidyut Vitran Nigam Limited & Ors (D.O.J. 16.11.2026)
Loading Viewer...






