This judgment by the Supreme Court of India addresses criminal appeals arising from a common judgment of the Punjab and Haryana High Court, which had upheld the conviction of the appellant (Naresh) for the brutal murders of two widows, Suman and Shakuntla, in village Ranila, Haryana, while acquitting his co-accused (Subhash). The High Court had commuted the appellant’s death sentence to life imprisonment. Upon a thorough re-evaluation of the record, the Supreme Court noted that every independent and material witness examined during the trial had turned hostile and disowned the prosecution’s version. The lower courts had erroneously relied upon police statements under Section 161 of the CrPC and hearsay FIR contents as substantive evidence, violating statutory prohibitions. Furthermore, the medical evidence, flawed weapon recoveries, and lack of forensic links failed to establish a complete chain of circumstantial evidence. Applying the principle of parity with the acquitted co-accused and the golden rules of proof for circumstantial cases, the Supreme Court allowed the appeals, set aside the conviction, and acquitted the appellant of all charges while recommending victim compensation through the District Legal Services Authority.
- Factual Background: On the intervening night of April 17/18, 2011, two widows—Suman (aged 35) and Shakuntla (aged 40)—were found brutally murdered in their respective homes in village Ranila, Bhiwani District, Haryana, after having been attacked with blunt and sharp-edged weapons. An FIR was registered against the appellant based on the statement of a village panch (PW-7) who was not an eyewitness and whose report was based on hearsay.
- Trial Court and High Court Proceedings:
- Trial Court: The Trial Court convicted both the appellant and co-accused Subhash under Sections 302, 449, 297, and 201 IPC, sentencing them to death. It relied extensively on the previous police statements of witnesses who had turned hostile in court, treating them as substantive evidence.
- High Court: The High Court acquitted co-accused Subhash of all charges, finding the evidence against him unreliable and contradictory. However, it upheld the appellant’s conviction solely because his name appeared in the FIR, commuting his death sentence to imprisonment for life.
- Supreme Court’s Legal Findings:
- Misuse of Police Statements (Section 162 CrPC): The Supreme Court strongly criticized the courts below for using statements recorded under Section 161 CrPC and the hearsay FIR as substantive proof of guilt, emphasizing that Section 162 CrPC strictly bars such use.
- Hostile Witnesses: The Court reiterated that when witnesses turn hostile, their previous police statements cannot be used as primary evidence to establish the prosecution’s case; at best, they can only impeach credit under specific statutory rules.
- Defective Recoveries and Medical Contradictions: The initial police theory claimed the murders were committed with a danda (blunt weapon). However, after post-mortem reports revealed fatal incised (sharp-edged) wounds, the police recorded second-round disclosure statements to introduce a gandasi. The Court held these disclosures unproven and inconsistent.
- Inconclusive Forensic Evidence: FSL reports detected human blood of an “inconclusive” group on clothes and no blood origin on the weapons, failing to connect the appellant to the crime.
- Principle of Parity: The Court ruled that the evidence used to acquit co-accused Subhash applied equally to the appellant; distinguishing them solely based on an FIR name was legally impermissible.
- Final Decision: The Supreme Court set aside the judgments of the High Court and Trial Court as they rested on inadmissible material and conjecture. The appellant was acquitted of all charges and ordered to be released immediately unless required in another case. Additionally, the Court recommended that the District Legal Services Authority, Bhiwani, consider granting victim compensation to the legal representatives of the deceased under the applicable Victim Compensation Scheme.
2026 INSC 1220
Naresh v. State of Haryana (D.O.J. 16.11.2026)
Loading Viewer...






