The present appeals arose from a judgment by the High Court of Delhi, which had dismissed the appellant-constable’s writ petition and upheld his penalty of removal from service for alleged gross misconduct, indiscipline, and insubordination. The charges against the appellant included sending a conditional resignation under pressure, alleged involvement in circulating a video of his ailing wife, and a past record of minor penalties. The Supreme Court examined the record and found that the departmental proceedings suffered from serious procedural lapses—including denying Hindi translations of crucial documents and refusing defense assistance—while noting that the appellant had acted under acute mental stress during a severe medical emergency involving his wife’s multiple miscarriages and surgeries. The Apex Court held that the charges were not sustainably established and that the extreme penalty of removal was shockingly disproportionate, setting aside the lower court judgments and ordering the appellant’s immediate reinstatement with 50% back wages and full consequential benefits.
- Background and Facts:
- The appellant, a Constable (General Duty) in the Central Industrial Security Force (CISF) appointed in 2012, faced severe medical complications regarding his wife’s pregnancy in late 2017, leading to a miscarriage, emergency hospitalizations, and major surgical procedures.
- Following an initial leave and a denied extension request amidst these distressing circumstances, the appellant tendered a conditional resignation through the grievance portal on December 6, 2017, while under acute mental stress.
- Although he subsequently resumed duty and was transferred, he was served with a Memorandum of Charge under Rule 36 of the CISF Rules, 2001, on his joining day, January 18, 2018.
- The Charges:
- Charge-I: Alleged refusal to appear before the Commandant on December 6, 2017, and submission of a conditional resignation to pressure unit administration.
- Charge-II: Alleged intimidation through relatives calling senior officials and alleged responsibility for a viral video of his wife criticizing unit authorities.
- Charge-III: Cited five past minor penalties over his service tenure to label him a habitual offender.
- Procedural Irregularities:
- The Supreme Court noted that the documents relied upon by the department were in English, a language the appellant was not conversant with. His repeated requests for Hindi translations were rejected and only furnished after the examination of prosecution witnesses had concluded, severely prejudicing his defense.
- Furthermore, his requests for a defense assistant were improperly turned down under Rule 36(8)(a) of the CISF Rules, 2001, violating principles of natural justice and preventing a fair opportunity to defend himself.
- Findings of the Court on Charges:
- On Charge-I: There was no specific written direction proved on record that the appellant deliberately disobeyed, and his resignation must be viewed in the proper context of his wife’s life-threatening medical emergency.
- On Charge-II: There was no satisfactory evidence connecting the appellant to the circulation of his wife’s hospital video or proving that he instigated external calls or threats by relatives.
- On Charge-III: Previous penalties for which the appellant had already undergone punishment cannot be treated as fresh instances of misconduct to supply deficiencies in proving current unproven charges.
- Relief Granted:
- Concluding that the punishment of removal was manifestly excessive, unduly harsh, and shockingly disproportionate to the proved facts, the Supreme Court allowed the appeals.
- The Court set aside the High Court’s orders and the departmental removal orders, ruling that remanding the matter for a fresh inquiry after such a long passage of time would serve no useful purpose.
- The appellant was ordered to be reinstated in service forthwith with 50% back wages from the date of removal until reinstatement, alongside all consequential benefits.
2026 INSC 1221
Sumit Kumar v. Union of India & Ors. (D.O.J. 16.11.2026)
Loading Viewer...






