The Division Bench of the High Court of Himachal Pradesh allowed a Letters Patent Appeal filed by the State, set aside the Single Judge’s order dated 11.10.2023, and remanded the writ petition for fresh consideration after noticing pre-existing 2014 revenue entries for statutory dues and the “as is where is” / “as is what is” terms of a private-treaty SARFAESI sale. Holding that these material facts had escaped consideration when the writ petition was allowed on the basis of earlier charge-priority precedents, the Court sent the matter back for a fresh decision.
- Single Judge Order & Challenge: The writ petitioner purchased factory land in Nalagarh (earlier owned by M/s Dev Bhumi Steels) through a private treaty under Rule 8(8) of the Security Interest (Enforcement) Rules, 2002 for Rs. 1,04,50,000/- (Rs. 50,000/- above the Rs. 1,04,00,000/- reserve price), with the Sale Certificate issued on 14.05.2018. Relying on Punjab National Bank (CWP No. 1638 of 2017), the Single Judge on 11.10.2023 quashed Tehsildar notices (dated 14.08.2019 and 16.08.2019) linked to dues of the Excise and Taxation Department (Rs. 1,80,50,073/-) and Electricity Board (Rs. 5,48,55,341/-).
- Pre-Existing Revenue Entries: The Division Bench noted that entries for the Electricity Department (16.01.2014) and Excise Department (16.05.2014) already existed in the revenue records prior to the 14.05.2018 Sale Certificate.
- “As Is Where Is” Terms & Encumbrances: In accepting the bank’s private-treaty offer on 10.05.2018, the purchaser acknowledged buying on an “as is where is” and “as is what is” basis after due diligence and undertook to bear statutory/non-statutory dues, taxes, and charges. A sale certificate stating freedom from encumbrances known to the secured creditor stood in sharp contrast to the recorded revenue entries.
- Failure to Consider Material Facts: The Division Bench observed that the Single Judge had not examined these facts and the effect of the “as is where is” purchase terms and substantial State dues when disposing of the petition.
- Remand Order: The appeal was allowed, the 11.10.2023 Single Judge order was set aside, and the case was remanded for fresh adjudication along with disposal of pending applications.
STPL (Web) 2026 HP 762
State of H.P. and Others vs. Darshan Singh and Another (D.O.J. 09.10.2026)
Loading Viewer...






