The High Court of Himachal Pradesh upheld the 2026 amendment to the Assistant Engineer (Civil) Recruitment and Promotion Rules, 2019, which merged separate promotional quotas for degree-holder Junior Engineers into a joint 29% quota. Holding that framing and amending service rules fall within the employer’s policy domain and were backed by valid administrative and regulatory reasons, the Court dismissed the challenge under Articles 14 and 16.
- Challenge to 2026 Amendment: The petitioners, Junior Engineers (Civil) who acquired graduation degrees during service, challenged Notification dated 11.02.2026 amending the 2019 Rules on the ground that merging their earlier 10% quota with the 15% quota for degree-holders entering with the qualification—into a joint 29% quota—eliminated their dedicated quota arbitrarily.
- Merger and Increase of Quota: Comparing the pre- and post-amendment rules, the Court noted that the combined accelerated quota for degree-holder Junior Engineers increased from 25% (10% in-service degree/AMIE plus 15% direct-entry degree/AMIE) to 29%, incorporating 4% from the Planning Officer cadre where eligible candidates were unavailable. Petitioners retained eligibility to compete under the 29% quota as well as the macro 45% quota.
- Administrative & Regulatory Rationale: The amendment was supported by valid reasons, including the de-recognition of distance-education AMIE degrees by AICTE and UGC from 31.05.2013 (with a cut-off rider added in the amended rules), vacancies remaining unfilled due to lack of eligible candidates in the AMIE and Planning Officer categories, and concurrence of relevant departments without any mala fides.
- Policy Domain & Promotion Rights: Relying on Supreme Court precedents including U. Joshi, Usha Kheterpal Waie, Triloki Nath Khosa, Mohammad Shujat Ali, and N. Lakshmana Rao, the Court held that determining qualifications, promotional avenues, and service conditions is a policy matter for the employer that can be unilaterally amended without violating Articles 14 and 16 so long as the right to be considered for promotion is not taken away.
- Decision: Finding no arbitrariness or unconstitutionality in the 11.02.2026 amendment, the High Court dismissed the writ petition along with pending miscellaneous applications.
STPL (Web) 2026 HP 753
Aman Parmar & Others vs. State of Himachal Pradesh and Others (D.O.J. 06.10.2026)
Loading Viewer...






