The High Court of Himachal Pradesh dismissed the State’s appeal and upheld the order dated 22.06.2019 of the Commissioner under the Employee’s Compensation Act awarding ₹3,12,940/- compensation with 12% annual interest from the date of accident for the fatal fall of an I&PH Fitter while repairing a water pipe. Holding that a regular government employee performing Schedule II duties is a workman under Section 2(1)(n) despite terminal/pensionary benefits or compassionate employment, and finding no error in calculation, limitation, interest, or procedure, the Court affirmed the award.
- Factual Background & Award: On 20.07.2006, I&PH Fitter Jaswant Singh (aged 49 years 6 months, earning ₹4,260/- plus allowances) died after falling from the second floor of a departmental building while repairing a water pipe. The Commissioner awarded ₹3,12,940/- with 12% simple interest from the accident date to the widow (60%) and daughter (40%), excluding the major son who had received compassionate employment.
- Workman Status Despite Service Benefits: Under Section 2(1)(n) and Schedule II clause (x) of the then Workmen’s Compensation Act, 1923 (applicable to the 2006 accident), repair of a pipe-line brings the employee within the Act. Citing State of Kerala v. Khadeeja Beevi (1989 ACJ 332) and District Forest Officer, Madurai Division v. P. Ganesan (2007 ACJ 1521), the Court held that regular government service, terminal dues/family pension, or compassionate appointment does not bar compensation under this welfare statute.
- Calculation, Interest, Limitation & Procedure: Applying Explanation II to Section 4(1)(a) (deemed monthly wage ₹4,000/-), 50% thereof (₹2,000/-) multiplied by Schedule IV factor 156.47 for age 49 years 6 months equals ₹3,12,940/-, and 12% interest from the accident date is mandatory under Section 4A(3)(a). Under Section 30 (Golla Rajanna, Sujatha, Fulmati Dhramdev Yadav), factual findings were not perverse, the department had notice/reports under Section 10, and active participation through counsel and witnesses (RW-1 and RW-2) showed no prejudice from not filing a formal reply.
- Decision: The appeal and pending miscellaneous applications were dismissed, upholding the Commissioner’s order dated 22.06.2019.
STPL (Web) 2026 HP 781
Secretary I&PH to the Government of H.P. Shimla vs. Sh. Vijay Chauhan and Others (D.O.J. 30.10.2026)
Loading Viewer...





