The High Court of Himachal Pradesh dismissed a second appeal by the defendants and upheld the First Appellate Court’s decree granting a permanent prohibitory injunction in favor of the plaintiff over the suit land. Holding that the plaintiff’s General Power of Attorney could competently depose regarding revenue-record-based ownership, possession, and apprehended interference without inviting an adverse inference, and that the defendants’ claim of total construction was unsupported by revenue entries or a demarcation report, the Court affirmed the injunction.
- Factual & Procedural Background: The plaintiff sued for a permanent prohibitory injunction (and demolition if needed) to restrain the defendants from interfering with or changing the nature of the suit land. The Trial Court dismissed the suit holding the entire land was constructed and no overt act was proved, whereas the First Appellate Court reversed and decreed the suit upon finding the plaintiff in possession and drawing an adverse inference against the defendants for not producing the demarcation report.
- GPA Witness & Absence of Adverse Inference: Citing Rattan Dev v. Pasam Devi, Gangavva v. Arjunsa, Janki Vashdeo Bhojwani v. IndusInd Bank Ltd., and Man Kaur v. Hartar Singh Sangha, the Court held that non-appearance of the plaintiff in the witness box was not fatal because ownership, possession, and threatened interference based on revenue records were not matters within the plaintiff’s exclusive personal knowledge.
- Revenue Entries, Demarcation & Injunction: The jamabandi entry (Ext. P1) carried a presumption of correctness and showed only partial uncultivable/cowshed entries rather than full construction across the suit land. Relying on Lakshmamma v. M.P. Krishnappa, Shri Ram v. Rakesh Kumar, and Atma Ram v. Onkar Singh, the Court held that the plaintiff’s lawful possession and reasonable apprehension of interference—reinforced by the defendants’ unsubstantiated plea and withheld demarcation report—justified a permanent injunction.
- Site Plan Not Mandatory: Following Ghisa Ram v. Sukhi Ram and Order VII Rule 3 CPC, the Court ruled that where the suit pertains to a whole Khasra number defined in revenue records, a separate site plan distinguishing constructed and vacant portions was not required.
- Decision: The regular second appeal and pending miscellaneous applications were dismissed, and records were ordered returned with a copy of the judgment.
STPL (Web) 2026 HP 772
Mathra Dass & Anr vs. Sukh Dei (Since Deceased) Through LR Ram Asra (D.O.J. 29.10.2026)
Loading Viewer...






