The High Court of Himachal Pradesh dismissed a writ petition challenging the selection of respondent No. 6 as Post-Graduate Teacher (Biology) under the School Management Committee (SMC) policy, holding that conducting a fresh selection aligned with statutory/SMC norms and that a last-minute land transfer did not confer permanent residency marks. Finding that the petitioner had lower overall merit and could not assail the selection criteria after participating without protest, the Court upheld the appointment.
- Factual Background: After serving as a Biology Lecturer from 15.06.2010 to 25.06.2015 at Baba Balak Nath Senior Secondary School, Chakmoh, the petitioner appeared in a fresh interview on 28.07.2015 pursuant to Recruitment Notice dated 13.07.2015. Respondent No. 6 was selected (36.6 marks) while the petitioner placed third (26.2 marks).
- Validity of Fresh SMC Selection: Under Section 21 of the Right of Children to Free and Compulsory Education Act, 2009 and the SMC Policy, undertaking a transparent selection process through a duly constituted committee to align with statutory and SMC norms was valid.
- Residency Marks & Pre-Interview Land Transfer: Under Clause 8(b) of the evaluation criteria (out of 60 marks), 10 marks were reserved for permanent residents of the Patwar Circle where the school was situated (Chakmoh). The petitioner’s actual residence/Parivar Register record showed Village Budhan under Gram Panchayat Sakroh, and a land transfer executed by her father on 15.07.2015—about thirteen days before the interview—did not make her a permanent resident of the Patwar Circle. Even if 10 marks were notionally added to her 26.2 marks, her score (36.2) remained below the selected candidate’s 36.6 marks.
- Estoppel & TET Plea Rejected: Relying on Madan Lal, Tejvir Singh Sodhi, Karunesh Kumar, and Air Commodore N.K. Sharma, the Court held that an unsuccessful candidate who participated without objection cannot challenge the selection criteria after losing out, absent proven mala fides or bias. The Court also rejected the unsubstantiated claim regarding TET eligibility for a PGT post.
- Decision: The writ petition and pending applications were dismissed, upholding the selection and appointment of respondent No. 6 with parties bearing their own costs.
STPL (Web) 2026 HP 765
Meena Kumari vs. State of H.P. and Others (D.O.J. 08.10.2026)
Loading Viewer...






