This landmark judgment by the Supreme Court disposes of a massive batch of appeals under Section 62 of the Insolvency and Bankruptcy Code, 2016 (IBC), arising out of the Corporate Insolvency Resolution Process (CIRP) of Videocon Industries Limited (VIL) and 12 group companies, alongside its subsidiary VOVL Limited. The appeals were broadly divided into two groups: Group I dealt with the Successful Resolution Applicant’s (Twinstar Technologies) challenge to the NCLAT’s decision setting aside its resolution plan and remitting the matter to the Committee of Creditors (CoC), primarily because the plan proposed paying dissenting financial creditors via non-convertible debentures (NCDs) rather than cash, violating Section 30(2)(b); and Group II addressed appeals by the erstwhile promoter (Venugopal Dhoot) and vendor associations seeking to include valuable foreign oil and gas assets held by downstream overseas subsidiaries into VIL’s domestic CIRP. The Supreme Court dismissed all appeals, upholding the NCLAT’s order to remand the resolution plan back to the CoC for fresh consideration and affirming that a holding company’s assets do not encompass those of its distinct legal subsidiaries under Section 18 Explanation (b) and Section 36(4)(d) of the Code. Furthermore, the Court laid down authoritative guardrails governing the power of appellate tribunals to remand resolution plans.
Part A: Group I – Appeals of the Successful Resolution Applicant (SRA)
- Background & NCLT/NCLAT Rulings:
- The consolidated CIRP of 13 Videocon group companies received a resolution plan from Twinstar Technologies Limited (SRA) with a financial outlay of ₹2,962.02 crores against admitted claims of over ₹64,838 crores (a ~95.85% haircut).
- The plan proposed paying dissenting financial creditors through long-term Non-Convertible Debentures (NCDs) redeemable over six years.
- The NCLT approved the plan with modifications directing upfront cash payment to dissenters.
- On appeal by dissenting creditors (Bank of Maharashtra, IFCI, SIDBI), the NCLAT set aside the approval, holding that deferred NCD payments violated Section 30(2)(b) (mandating cash payout matching liquidation value as per Jaypee Kensington), and remitted the matter back to the CoC.
- Supreme Court’s Analysis & Findings:
- Jurisdiction and Power to Remand: The NCLAT possesses implicit and explicit powers to remand a defective plan to the CoC, preventing the binary trap of choosing between a non-compliant plan and liquidation. The 2026 amendment to Section 31(2) further statutory backs this remedial course.
- Violation of Section 30(2)(b): Following Jaypee Kensington, “payment” to dissenting financial creditors under Section 30(2)(b) must be in money/cash, not in the form of deferred securities or barter instruments like NCDs.
- CoC’s Role and Status: The CoC does not become functus officio upon approving a plan; it remains active until the plan is fully implemented or liquidation is ordered. Given that the approval was challenged and stayed via interim orders, the CoC acted lawfully in seeking reconsideration.
- Guardrails on Remand: The Court articulated explicit guardrails guiding appellate remands: they must promote the Code’s objectives (going concern, asset maximization, fair recovery), rest on legal non-compliance under Section 61(3), be used sparingly, serve a corrective function against NCLT modifications, and incorporate strict timelines.
Part B: Group II – Appeals Concerning Foreign Oil and Gas Assets
- Nature of the Dispute: The erstwhile promoter and the VIL Vendors Association argued that valuable participating interests in oil and gas concessions in Brazil and Indonesia (held via downstream foreign subsidiaries such as VOVL, VHHL, VEBL, and VINI) should be sucked into VIL’s domestic CIRP under a “single economic unit” or corporate veil-lifting doctrine.
- Supreme Court’s Analysis & Findings:
- Separate Legal Entity & Statutory Exclusion: Under corporate law principles (Vodafone International) and express statutory mandates—specifically Section 18 Explanation (b) and Section 36(4)(d) of the Code—assets of an Indian or foreign subsidiary are strictly excluded from the corporate debtor’s estate and liquidation pool.
- Estoppel and Conduct of the Promoter: The promoter was barred by conduct, estoppel, and previous representations (having actively sought to exclude offshore assets from debt obligations and failing to challenge prior dismissal orders for consolidation) from turning around to claim them.
- Valid Third-Party Transactions: Third-party transactions—such as BPRL exercising its pre-existing Right of First Refusal (ROFR) under the Quotaholders’ Agreement for the Brazilian assets—were validly approved by VOVL’s CoC and concluded lawfully, protecting heavy capital infusions made to prevent forfeiture.
Final Disposition
- Civil Appeal Nos. 894, 512, and 509 of 2022 (SRA Appeals):
- Civil Appeal No. 1307 of 2022, 8659-8661 of 2026, 8718-8719 of 2026, and Diary Nos. 41234 & 41286 of 2026 (Promoter/Vendor Appeals):
- Interlocutory Applications: Interventions by GAIL and Union of India disposed of with liberty to agitate their claims/contentions before the RP and Adjudicating Authority in accordance with the law.
2026 INSC 1214
Twinstar Technologies Limited v. Bank of Maharashtra & Ors. (D.O.J. 16.11.2026)
Loading Viewer...






