The High Court of Himachal Pradesh partly allowed the insurance company’s appeal and modified the Motor Accident Claims Tribunal award dated 01.04.2017 by reducing the compensation from ₹10,68,000/- to ₹9,26,800/- and lowering the interest rate from 9% to 7.5% per annum from the date of filing until deposit, while retaining insurer liability. Holding that sworn eye-witness testimony outweighed a police cancellation report on the preponderance of probabilities, the Court recalculated compensation using 40% future prospects under Pranay Sethi.
- Background & Award: Claimants sought ₹12,000,000/- under Section 166 of the Motor Vehicles Act after 26-year-old Gurbaksh Singh died on 10.02.2016 when his motorcycle was hit by vehicle No. HP72-5426. The Tribunal awarded ₹10,68,000/- with 9% annual interest against the insurer.
- Negligence & Police Cancellation Report: In summary MACT proceedings governed by preponderance of probabilities, sworn testimony of eye-witness/FIR informant Sanjeev Kumar (PW-3) was not displaced by police cancellation report Ext. R-1, especially where the insurer examined none of the police-cited witnesses or confronted PW-3 with his later statement.
- Income, Future Prospects & Multiplier: The Court upheld the monthly income of ₹6,000/- for the unmarried unorganized-sector worker and multiplier of 17 (Sarla Verma), but adjusted future prospects from 50% to 40% (₹8,400/-) under National Insurance Co. Ltd. v. Pranay Sethi ((2017) 16 SCC 680) and deducted 50% for personal expenses (₹4,200/-), yielding loss of income of ₹8,56,800/-.
- Conventional Heads & Interest: Replacing the Tribunal’s conventional awards with Pranay Sethi figures—₹40,000/- for loss of consortium, ₹15,000/- for loss of estate, and ₹15,000/- for funeral expenses—resulted in total compensation of ₹9,26,800/-, with interest reduced to 7.5% per annum.
- Decision: The appeal was partly allowed, modifying total compensation to ₹9,26,800/- with 7.5% annual interest from filing until deposit, with parties bearing their own costs and records ordered returned.
STPL (Web) 2026 HP 782
United India Insurance Company Ltd. vs. Champa Devi & Others (D.O.J. 31.10.2026)
Loading Viewer...





