The High Court of Himachal Pradesh allowed the insurance company’s appeal and modified the Motor Accident Claims Tribunal award dated 28.08.2025 by setting aside the “pay and recover” direction against the insurer and holding the owner of the goods vehicle directly liable to satisfy the compensation award. Holding that Section 147 of the Motor Vehicles Act does not cover gratuitous passengers in a goods carriage and that a Claims Tribunal lacks extraordinary Article 142 powers to order pay-and-recover against the insurer, the Court fastened liability squarely on the vehicle owner.
- Background & Award: Claimants sought compensation under Section 166 of the Motor Vehicles Act following the death of Abhimanyu @ Pappu in an accident on 31.05.2017 involving Mahindra Pick-up No. HP-71-4783. The Tribunal awarded ₹14,79,080/- with 6% annual interest and, while finding the deceased to be an unauthorized/gratuitous passenger, directed the insurer to pay first and recover from the owner under “pay and recover”.
- No Statutory Liability for Gratuitous Passenger: Relying on New India Assurance Co. Ltd. v. Asha Rani ((2003) 2 SCC 223) and National Insurance Co. Ltd. v. Baljit Kaur ((2004) 2 SCC 1), the Court held that under Section 147 of the Motor Vehicles Act, 1988, a goods carriage is not meant for carrying passengers and “any person” does not cover gratuitous passengers. Because the finding that the deceased was a gratuitous passenger had attained finality, the insurer owed no statutory liability.
- No Tribunal Power Under Article 142: Addressing Baljit Kaur, Saju P. Paul, Manuara Khatun, and Parvathneni ((2018) 9 SCC 657), the Court held that pay-and-recover directions in those Supreme Court decisions rested on extraordinary power under Article 142 of the Constitution, which a Claims Tribunal does not possess, making the pay-and-recover order legally unsustainable.
- Decision: The appeal was allowed, the pay-and-recover direction against the appellant-insurer was set aside, the vehicle owner (respondent No. 1) was held liable to satisfy the award, the remaining terms of the award were kept intact, and pending applications were disposed of.
STPL (Web) 2026 HP 786
Oriental Insurance Company Ltd. vs. Sumitra Devi & Others (D.O.J. 05.11.2026)
Loading Viewer...





