The High Court of Himachal Pradesh allowed a writ petition by direct-recruit Assistant Engineers (Civil) and quashed the seniority memoranda dated 24.05.2011 and 25.05.2011 that placed them en-bloc below promotees of 2008, directing that their seniority be fixed as per the prescribed roster under the 2005 R&P Rules with consequential benefits. Holding that promotions in excess of quota/roster and administrative delays after recommendation in a 2008 recruitment drive cannot defeat direct recruits’ roster placement, the Court found the State’s action arbitrary and violative of Articles 14 and 16 of the Constitution.
- Background & Seniority Dispute: Following an advertisement in 2008 for 15 Assistant Engineer (Civil) direct-recruitment posts, the Commission recommended the petitioners on 04.11.2008, approval and medical/antecedent formalities were completed in November–December 2008, and appointment letters were issued on 09.01.2009. Meanwhile, promotions were effected in 2008 (including after a 30.12.2008 DPC), and seniority memoranda dated 24.05.2011 and 25.05.2011 placed the petitioners en-bloc below 2008 promotees.
- Rota-Quota, Roster & Excess Promotions: Under the R&P Rules (25% direct recruitment, 75% promotion with sub-quotas) and roster notification dated 25.02.2005, seniority between direct recruits and promotees must follow the prescribed roster. Citing G. Jaisinghani (AIR 1967 SC 1427), V.B. Badami (AIR 1980 SC 1561), and H.V. Pardasani ((1985) 2 SCC 468), the Court held that excess promotions beyond quota or upgraded posts cannot be given seniority over direct recruits in breach of the roster.
- Effect of Recruitment Year & Delay: Relying on All India Judges Association (2025 INSC 1328) and distinguishing Thanigivelu (Civil Appeal No. 862 of 2026), the Court held that where recruitment was initiated in 2008 and recommendations/formalities occurred before year-end, subsequent administrative delays or induction-training date formalities until 09.01.2009 could not deprive direct recruits of their 2008 roster placement.
- Decision: The writ petition was allowed, memoranda dated 24.05.2011 and 25.05.2011 were quashed, and the State was directed to assign seniority to the petitioners per the roster under the 2005 R&P Rules (notified 25.02.2005) with all consequential benefits, with no order as to costs.
STPL (Web) 2026 HP 780
Vivek Katoch and Others vs. State of H.P. and Others (D.O.J. 30.10.2026)
Loading Viewer...






