The High Court of Himachal Pradesh dismissed a writ petition filed by Auxiliary Nurse Midwives (ANMs) seeking to quash or amend Recruitment and Promotion Rules requiring the minimum educational qualification prescribed for direct recruitment to be eligible for promotion to Staff Nurse. Holding that prescribing qualifications lies within the employer’s policy domain and that feeder-post experience cannot automatically substitute required qualifications for a higher post, the Court upheld the rules.
- Factual Background & Claim: Petitioners serving as ANMs challenged Clause 11 of the Recruitment and Promotion Rules for Staff Nurse, which conditioned the 25% promotion quota (alongside 3 years of service) on possessing the educational qualification in Column 7(a) (10+2 preferably with science, A-grade GNM or B.Sc. Nursing, and Nursing Council registration). They sought promotion based on experience/seniority or training, or parity with other posts/departments.
- Employer’s Domain & Non-Arbitrariness: Relying on U. Joshi v. Accountant General, Ahmedabad ((2003) 2 SCC 632) and Chandigarh Administration v. Usha Kheterpal Waie ((2011) 9 SCC 645), the Court held that framing service rules and prescribing qualifications belong to the employer/State unless unconstitutional, arbitrary under Article 14, or lacking a rational nexus with the duties of the post.
- Experience vs. Qualification & Analogies Rejected: The Court held that experience as an ANM did not substitute the unchallenged minimum qualification required for the superior post of Staff Nurse. Distinguishing N. Saxena v. NDMC ((1990) 4 SCC 205) on its distinct rule text and rejecting analogies to Assistant Engineers or Male Health Supervisors (100% promotional), the Court found no discrimination.
- Decision & Liberty: Dismissing the writ petition and pending applications, the Court observed that dismissal would not bar petitioners from approaching authorities under Clause 18 of the R&P Rules.
STPL (Web) 2026 HP 776
Sheela Devi and Others vs. State of H.P. and Another (D.O.J. 28.10.2026)
Loading Viewer...






