The High Court of Himachal Pradesh dismissed a petition seeking to change the petitioner’s compassionate appointment status from contractual Clerk to regular Clerk from her initial joining in 2007, upholding the rejection order dated 23.06.2012. Holding that no regular Clerk appointments were made on compassionate grounds after 2003, that Clause 11 of the compassionate policy bars changing post status after unprotested acceptance, and that compassionate appointment is not a source of endless relief, the Court rejected the claim.
- Factual Background & Claim: Appointed on compassionate grounds as a Clerk on contract basis in the Police Department in June/July 2007 after her husband went missing while in service, the petitioner sought regularization from her initial joining with consequential benefits. She challenged the rejection order dated 23.06.2012 (referred to as 23.07.2012 in the prayer clause).
- No Regular Clerk Appointments After 2003: Out of 28 compassionate Clerk appointments in the Police Department from 2001, only 2 were regular (in 2003) and 26 were contractual under the State’s contractual policy, with no regular Clerk appointments made after 2003. The petitioner also could not claim parity with Constables governed by different rules (Rule 12.12 of the Punjab Police Rules).
- Clause 11 & Consummation of Right: Under Clause 11 of the Compassionate Appointment Policy dated 18.01.1990, a dependent who accepts an offered compassionate appointment without demur has no right or locus to seek a change in post, status, or nomenclature. Relying on Director of Town Panchayat v. M. Jayabal (2025 SCC OnLine SC 2794) and Surinder Kumar v. State of H.P. (CWPOA No. 2668 of 2019), the Court held that once accepted, the right of consideration stands consummated and cannot yield endless compassion.
- Subsequent Superannuation: The Court also noted that the petitioner had already superannuated from promotional posts during the pendency of the proceedings.
- Decision: The petition and pending miscellaneous applications were dismissed, upholding the rejection order with parties bearing their own costs.
STPL (Web) 2026 HP 767
Janak Dulari vs. State of Himachal Pradesh and Another (D.O.J. 15.10.2026)
Loading Viewer...






