The High Court of Himachal Pradesh quashed Notification dated 13.02.2009 promoting respondent No. 4 as Head of Department (Computer Engineering) and ordered a review DPC, holding that a direct recruit appointed later from a waiting list cannot be placed above an earlier-joining Lecturer in the combined seniority list for promotion. The Court further held that the Public Service Commission lacked authority to determine inter-se seniority across separate selections once recommendations were made.
- Factual Background & Promotion Challenge: The petitioner joined as Lecturer (Computer Application) on 16.02.1998 (pursuant to offer dated 06.02.1998), whereas respondent No. 4, initially on a waiting list for Lecturer (Computer Engineering), was offered appointment on 17.03.1998 and joined on 26.03.1998 after serial No. 1 did not join. Based on a combined seniority list dated 18.10.2008 placing respondent No. 4 above the petitioner, respondent No. 4 was promoted as Head of Department (Computer Engineering) on 13.02.2009.
- Combined Seniority & Date of Appointment: Under Rule 11 of the R&P Rules, promotion to HOD (Computer Engineering) uses a combined seniority list of Lecturers (Computer Engineering/Computer Application) based on length of service in the respective grade without disturbing unit-wise inter-se seniority. Relying on Gujarat State Dy. Executive Engineers Association, Suraj Parkash Gupta, and Sri Kant Tripathi, the Court held that a direct recruit’s seniority runs from regular appointment/joining and a waitlisted candidate joining later cannot claim seniority over an earlier appointee.
- Lack of PSC Authority Over Inter-Se Seniority: Rejecting the argument that the petitioner had not separately challenged the 18.10.2008 list, the Court held that the Public Service Commission had no authority to fix inter-se seniority across two distinct posts/cadres recruited under separate advertisements once its recommendation function ended.
- Review DPC & Consequential Relief: The Court quashed Notification dated 13.02.2009 and directed respondents No. 1 to 3 to hold a review DPC within three months to consider the petitioner for promotion, and if found eligible, promote him from 13.02.2009 with all consequential benefits, without costs.
STPL (Web) 2026 HP 764
Puneet Sood vs. State of H.P and Others (D.O.J. 13.10.2026)
Loading Viewer...






