The High Court of Himachal Pradesh upheld the amendment reducing the direct recruitment age limit for Junior T/Mates from 18–45 years to 18–30 years under the HPSEBL Recruitment & Promotion Rules, holding that prescribing age limits and amending service rules are policy matters within the employer’s domain. Finding that the change followed due deliberation and was justified by the physically demanding nature of the duties, the Court dismissed the challenge under Article 14.
- Challenge to Age Limit Amendment: The petitioners challenged notification dated 16.07.2014 amending the R&P Rules for Junior T/Mate (Operation Wing) in HPSEBL to lower the direct recruitment age bracket from 18–45 years to 18–30 years, claiming it rendered them overage and violated Article 14.
- Employer’s Policy Domain: Relying on U. Joshi v. Accountant General, Ahmedabad ((2003) 2 SCC 632) and Subodh Kumar v. Commissioner of Police (AIR 2020 SC 1427), the Court reiterated that framing or amending recruitment rules, prescribing age limits, and determining relaxations are policy matters for the employer or rule-making authority.
- Rationale of Field Duties: The Court found valid justification in reducing the upper age limit to 30 years because Junior T/Mates perform field work—such as climbing high poles—requiring young and physically capable personnel.
- Due Process & No Arbitrariness: The amendment was finalized after consultation with the State Government, deliberation by the Service Committee, and ratification by the Board of Directors, with no mala fides or ulterior motive shown. Loss of eligibility or reduced chances for older candidates alone does not make a rule arbitrary or unconstitutional.
- Final Outcome: Finding no merit in the petition, the High Court dismissed it along with any pending miscellaneous applications.
STPL (Web) 2026 HP 750
Balwant Singh and Another vs. Himachal Pradesh State Electricity Board Ltd and Others (D.O.J. 01.10.2026)
Loading Viewer...






