This judgment by the Supreme Court of India addresses a service dispute involving a constable in the Central Reserve Police Force (CRPF) who was removed from service for overstaying his sanctioned casual leave by 99 days. The appellant defended his absence on the ground of severe illness (infective hepatitis) and supported his claim with medical prescriptions, pathological reports, and a fitness certificate, which the Enquiry Officer dismissed as fabricated based on speculative observations. While a Single Judge of the High Court set aside the penalty, the Division Bench reversed that decision via a Letters Patent Appeal. Upon final review, the Supreme Court held that rejecting medical records on mere conjectures and surmises without verification was legally unsustainable, and that the extreme penalty of removal from service for 99 days of absence under these circumstances was grossly disproportionate. Consequently, the Supreme Court allowed the appeal, restored the Single Judge’s order, and directed the appellant’s reinstatement with 50% back wages and consequential benefits.
- Factual Background: The appellant, a constable posted with the 54th Battalion CRPF at Anantnag, J&K, was granted casual leave from September 21 to October 12, 2000, for his wife’s illness. He failed to rejoin on October 13, 2000, and ultimately resumed duty on January 19, 2001, overstaying his leave by 99 days.
- Departmental Proceedings and Penalty: The appellant explained that he had fallen ill with infective hepatitis at his village in Bihar and produced medical documents, prescriptions, and a fit certificate. The Enquiry Officer disregarded these documents on speculative grounds, such as the absence of indoor/outdoor patient numbers and the supposition that the notes were written with the same pen. Based on this, the disciplinary authority imposed the penalty of “Removal from Service,” which was subsequently upheld through departmental appeal and revision.
- Litigation Journey:
- Single Judge: The learned Single Judge quashed the removal order, ruling that the rejection of medical documents rested on conjectures and surmises.
- Division Bench: On appeal, the Division Bench set aside the Single Judge’s order, concluding that the Single Judge had exceeded the scope of judicial review by reappreciating evidence.
- Supreme Court’s Findings:
- Distinction Between Unauthorised and Wilful Absence: The Court noted that unauthorized absence and wilful absence are not synonymous; the explanation, supporting materials, and circumstances beyond an employee’s control must be weighed.
- Speculative Fact-Finding: The Enquiry Officer’s inference of fabrication based on ink color or lack of registration numbers—without any verification from the treating doctor or pharmacy—was flawed and amounted to conjectures.
- Proportionality of Punishment: Even for a member of a disciplined force, the extreme penalty of removal from service for a 99-day overstay, supported by medical explanations, was grossly disproportionate.
- Final Orders: The Supreme Court set aside the Division Bench’s judgment, restored the Single Judge’s order, and directed that the appellant be reinstated with immediate effect, granting him 50% back wages for the period of removal along with full consequential benefits.
2026 INSC 1219
Mithilesh Kumar Pathak v. Union of India & Ors. (D.O.J. 16.11.2026)
Loading Viewer...






