SC Dismisses Challenge to Midway Introduction of Written Examination in Nagaland Excise Recruitment

This civil appeal challenged a judgment of the Division Bench of the Gauhati High Court, Kohima Bench, which had set aside a Single Judge’s order and permitted the recruitment process for 46 Excise Constable posts in Nagaland to proceed. The appellants contested the introduction of a written examination via a corrigendum midway through the recruitment process, arguing it violated the initial advertisement and rules. The Supreme Court dismissed the appeal, holding that the Nagaland Excise Service (Revised) Rules, 1999 permit a competitive examination/selection, that the written test was a valid and objective method to shortlist an overwhelming number of applicants (over 11,000 applications for 46 posts), and that the appellants—having participated in the revised process—could not challenge it.

  • Factual Background & Recruitment Process:
    • The Department of Excise and Prohibition, Government of Nagaland, initiated recruitment for 40 Excise Constable posts (later increased to 46) requiring a Class VIII educational qualification.
    • The initial advertisement dated 07.04.2025 indicated a Physical Test and a Suitability Test/Viva-Voce.
    • Due to an exceptionally large response of 11,521 applications, a Corrigendum dated 04.06.2025 was issued introducing a written examination based on the Class VIII standard to shortlist candidates objectively before the interview stage.
  • Litigation History:
    • Single Judge: Allowed the writ petition filed by the appellants, quashing the corrigendum and physical test on the grounds that selection criteria could not be altered midway after the recruitment had commenced.
    • Division Bench: Allowed the State’s appeal, setting aside the Single Judge’s order and permitting the selection process to conclude. The final select list of 46 candidates was subsequently notified on June 29, 2026.
  • Supreme Court’s Reasoning and Findings:
    • Statutory Compliance: The recruitment is governed by the Nagaland Excise Service (Revised) Rules, 1999. Rule 5(i)(a) provides for direct recruitment through “competitive examination/selection”, meaning the introduction of a written examination fully conformed to the statutory rules without requiring external commission consultations.
    • Status of the Memorandum: The Court upheld the Division Bench’s view that a 2016 departmental memorandum relied upon by the appellants had neither been confirmed by the Selection Board nor officially notified, serving at best as a general guide for minimum standards rather than barring procedure modifications.
    • Authority of the Board: Clauses 15 and 16 of the advertisement expressly empowered the Departmental Recruitment Board to rectify omissions, issue addenda/notifications, and take final decisions in recruitment disputes.
    • Curbing Subjectivity & Managing Volume: Given the massive pool of over 11,000 applicants for only 46 posts, an objective written examination avoided placing disproportionate, subjective weight on interviews alone and ensured a fair evaluation on a common basis.
    • Estoppel by Participation: The Court emphasized that several appellants had actively participated in both the physical test and the written examination, and thus could not turn around to challenge the process after failing to secure selection.
  • Final Outcome: The civil appeal was dismissed, affirming the Division Bench’s judgment and leaving the finalized recruitment intact.

2026 INSC 1211

T. Akon Phom and Others v. State of Nagaland and Others (D.O.J 16.11.2026)

Loading Viewer...

Next Story

Supreme Court Quashes School Teacher Termination Due to Familial Bias in Inquiry

This appeal arose from a judgment passed by the High Court of Bombay (Nagpur Bench), which had upheld the termination of an Assistant Teacher by a school management committee. The appellant challenged her termination on the ground that the departmental inquiry was vitiated by severe institutional and personal bias, owing to a “total familial capture” of the management and the inquiry apparatus. The Supreme Court examined whether overlapping roles (with the Secretary acting as complainant, witness, and prosecutor, and his real brother serving as the Convenor of the Inquiry Committee) gave rise to a reasonable likelihood of bias. Holding that the rules of natural justice were fundamentally breached and that the doctrine of necessity did not apply, the Supreme Court set aside the High Court’s judgment, restored the School Tribunal’s order of reinstatement with back wages, and directed authorities to consider absorbing the teacher in another hundred per cent grant-in-aid school.

  • Factual Background: The appellant was appointed as an Assistant Teacher in 2009, with her appointment approved in 2015. After the school received a 20% grant-in-aid status, her name was allegedly excluded from salary grant bills by the Secretary (Rajesh Masurkar), prompting her to lodge complaints with the Education Department. Subsequently, the management initiated departmental disciplinary proceedings against her, leading to her termination in February 2022.
  • Proceedings Below: The School Tribunal initially quashed the termination and ordered reinstatement with full back wages. Upon remand by the High Court, the Tribunal reaffirmed its order, noting that the inquiry was a farce and that the Secretary could not act as a judge in his own cause. However, the High Court allowed the management’s writ petition and upheld the termination, concluding that the inquiry followed due process.
  • Core Issue on Bias: The Supreme Court considered whether the circumstances gave rise to a reasonable likelihood of bias from the perspective of a fair-minded person. The Court observed that the Executive Committee was dominated by a single family (the Masurkars). Specifically, Rajesh Masurkar acted simultaneously as the employer’s secretary, the CEO who issued the charge-sheet, a principal witness on multiple charges, and the person who signed the termination order, while his real brother (Prakash Masurkar) served as the Convenor (“Judge”) of the Inquiry Committee.
  • Legal Principles Invocations:
    • The Court reaffirmed that the test for bias is not actual proof of partiality, but a “reasonable likelihood of bias” or “real possibility of bias” from the standpoint of a fair-minded observer.
    • The maxim Nemo Judex in Causa Sua (no one should be a judge in their own cause) is a constitutional imperative under Article 14. Its breach is a foundational jurisdictional defect that cannot be cured by mere compliance with procedural formalities.
    • Close kinship disqualifies a person from adjudicating where it creates a reasonable apprehension of bias, and administrative tribunals are held to the same rigorous standards as courts.
    • The Doctrine of Necessity did not apply because other unrelated members of the Executive Committee were available to serve as the Convenor.
  • Relief Granted: The Supreme Court allowed the appeal, set aside the High Court’s judgment, and restored the School Tribunal’s order quashing the termination. Additionally, it directed the Education Officer to explore absorbing the appellant into another 100% grant-in-aid school under relevant service rules.

2026 INSC 1229

Ku. Kiran D/O Purushottam Bhujade v. Sudhir Shikshan Sanstha & Ors. (D.O.J. 17.11.2026)

Loading Viewer...

Next Story

NCLT: Protecting Bona Fide Third-Party Transactions

his civil appeal challenged concurrent orders of the National Company Law Tribunal (NCLT) and the National Company Law Appellate Tribunal (NCLAT), which had declared a company board resolution and a registered land sale deed as null and void under Section 241 of the Companies Act, 2013. The Supreme Court allowed the appeal filed by the third-party purchaser (Elaine Info Solutions Pvt. Ltd.), holding that the doctrine of indoor management protects bona fide third parties dealing with a company director holding a certified board resolution. The Court found that the mother (co-director and 50% shareholder) had full knowledge of the transaction, having personally signed the audited financial statements and balance sheet containing express notes acknowledging the sale. Consequently, the Supreme Court set aside the lower tribunal orders and dismissed the company petition.

  • Background of the Dispute: M/s J & A Avenues India Private Limited owned land which was sold to the appellant company (Elaine Info Solutions) via a registered sale deed dated September 4, 2015, pursuant to a board resolution dated August 1, 2015, executed by the son (who managed day-to-day affairs).
  • NCLT & NCLAT Proceedings: The mother (holding 50% shares and a directorship) filed a petition under Section 241 of the Companies Act, 2013, claiming oppression and mismanagement and alleging that she had no notice of the board meeting. The NCLT and NCLAT ruled in her favor, declaring the sale void ab initio, ordering the cancellation of the registered document, and penalizing the son.
  • Application of the Doctrine of Indoor Management: The Supreme Court held that the lower tribunals erred in placing the burden on an unrelated third-party purchaser to prove internal company notice. A third-party purchaser is entitled to rely in good faith on a board resolution produced by a director and 50% shareholder, protected squarely by the Doctrine of Indoor Management.
  • Acquiescence via Audited Financial Statements: The Court highlighted that the company’s audited balance sheets and financial statements for the relevant period—which were signed by the mother herself—explicitly contained “Note 14,” acknowledging the execution of the sale deed for the subject agricultural land and noting that the transaction was subject to a pending suit for specific performance.
  • Time-Barred Challenge: Because the mother signed the financial disclosures explicitly acknowledging the sale on September 2, 2016, her petition filed on October 8, 2018, challenging the 2015 sale deed was clearly an afterthought aimed at countering the specific performance suit, and filed after the expiry of the limitation period.

Final Ruling: The Supreme Court allowed the appellant’s appeal, dismissed the mother’s company petition, and set aside the NCLT and NCLAT orders. It clarified that the merits of the pending civil suit for specific performance (O.S. No. 15/2016) remain open for independent adjudication.

2026 INSC 1228

Elaine Info Solutions Pvt. Ltd. v. M/s. J & A Avenues India Private Limited and Ors. (with Civil Appeal No. 6250 of 2021) (D.O.J. 16.11.2026)

Loading Viewer...

Next Story

Amicable Resolution and Dissolution of Marriage

This criminal appeal arose from a series of protracted matrimonial and domestic violence proceedings between Ankit Saraiya (Appellant-Husband) and Pooja Saraiya (Respondent-Wife). During the pendency of the appeal before the Supreme Court, the parties successfully engaged in settlement discussions and arrived at a comprehensive, amicable resolution covering permanent alimony, a trust for their minor child, residential accommodations, custody/parenting arrangements, and the closure of all multi-forum litigations. Exercising its extraordinary powers under Article 142 of the Constitution of India, the Supreme Court dissolved the marriage, incorporated the settlement terms into the order, and directed the closure of all connected pending cases.

  • Background of Litigation: The parties were married on January 31, 2013, and had a son born in 2017. Following marital discord, multiple litigations ensued, including proceedings under Section 12 of the Protection of Women from Domestic Violence Act, 2005, criminal complaints/FIRs, civil suits, and maintenance disputes across various forums in Kolkata.
  • Amicable Settlement Reached: Upon encouragement by the Supreme Court to explore a settlement, the parties reached an extensive agreement to bring a complete quietus to all disputes.
  • Key Terms of the Settlement:
    • Permanent Alimony: A sum of ₹30 crores is payable to the Respondent-Wife.
    • Child Trust: A sum of ₹45 crores is payable for the minor child, to be held in trust by the Respondent-Wife.
    • Residential Arrangement: A residence worth up to ₹5 crores will be purchased out of the trust funds for the wife’s habitation until she remarries or the child turns 25, whichever is earlier.
    • Possession & Alimony Handover: Permanent alimony is to be paid via Demand Draft simultaneously with the handover of vacant and peaceful possession of the family home at Hastings Park Road, Kolkata, within a week.
    • Parenting Plan: The father’s visitation rights will be governed by the Calcutta High Court’s parenting plan, with provisions for good-faith resolution or judicial recourse in case of disagreements.
    • Closure of Cases: A total of 14 distinct pending proceedings—including Act VIII cases, multiple FIRs, criminal revisions, matrimonial suits, civil suits, and execution cases—are agreed to be closed.
  • Invocation of Article 142: Noting the irretrievable breakdown of marriage and the comprehensive settlement agreed upon by both sides, the Supreme Court invoked its powers under Article 142 of the Constitution to formally dissolve the marriage between Ankit Saraiya and Pooja Saraiya, disposing of the appeal and all pending applications in terms of the settlement.

2026 INSC 1227

Ankit Saraiya v. Pooja Saraiya (D.O.J. 16.11.2026)

Loading Viewer...

Next Story

Supreme Court Enhances Compensation for 7+ Years of Unlawful Post-Acquittal Detention

This criminal appeal addressed a profound violation of fundamental rights where the appellant, Devilal Gond, was incarcerated for an additional 7 years, 3 months, and 21 days after being acquitted by the High Court of Chhattisgarh. While the High Court acknowledged this illegal detention as a severe breach of Article 21 of the Constitution, it awarded a meager compensation of Rs. 2,00,000. The Supreme Court enhanced the compensation to Rs. 30,00,000, emphasizing that public law remedies based on strict liability must provide meaningful restitution for state-induced institutional apathy. Furthermore, the Court issued sweeping directives to all High Courts nationwide to implement digital criminal justice tracking ecosystems and institutional safeguards to ensure no prisoner languishes behind bars post-acquittal.

  • Initial Conviction and Subsequent Acquittal: The appellant was arrested on December 7, 2012, under Section 302 IPC, and subsequently convicted and sentenced to life imprisonment by the Sessions Court on August 14, 2013. On January 20, 2018, the High Court allowed the appellant’s criminal appeal, setting aside his conviction and fully acquitting him.
  • Prolonged Unlawful Incarceration: Due to a failure in communication and administrative coordination between the courts and jail authorities, the acquittal order was not acted upon, and the appellant remained unlawfully confined for an additional 7 years, 3 months, and 29 days until his release on May 19, 2025.
  • High Court’s Findings on Article 21 Violation: The appellant filed a writ petition seeking compensation for his prolonged illegal detention. While the High Court of Chhattisgarh strongly condemned the institutional apathy and ruled that his continued detention violated Article 21, it erred by awarding a nominal compensation of only Rs. 2,00,000.
  • Public Law Remedy and Strict Liability: Reviewing established jurisprudence (Nilabati Behera, Rudul Sah, K. Basu), the Supreme Court reiterated that monetary compensation under public law is a remedy based on strict liability, to which the defense of sovereign immunity does not apply. The State is vicariously liable to pay compensation for infringement of fundamental rights by its officers.
  • Assessment of Harm and Enhanced Compensation: The Supreme Court noted that the appellant lost the prime years of his youth—being confined from age 21 to 35 (with over 7 years spent behind bars after his innocence was legally established)—resulting in severe loss of liberty, livelihood, health, and social reintegration prospects. The total compensation was enhanced to 30,00,000 to ensure financial independence and sustainable rehabilitation.
  • Safeguards and National Directives: To prevent such systemic failures, the Supreme Court directed all High Courts across India to consider adopting institutional safeguards modeled after the Madhya Pradesh High Court’s protocols and to establish an integrated Online Criminal Justice Ecosystem linking police, prisons, courts, and legal services authorities.

2026 INSC 1226

Devilal Gond v. State of Chhattisgarh & Ors.(D.O.J. 16.11.2026)

Loading Viewer...

Recent Articles