The High Court of Himachal Pradesh dismissed a writ petition challenging the selection process for Assistant Engineer (Civil) conducted by the H.P. Public Service Commission where final merit was determined solely on a 100-mark interview after a screening test. Holding that the petitioners applied with full knowledge of the advertised criteria, participated without protest, and could not approbate and reprobate after being left out of the select list, the Court upheld the selection.
- Background & Grievance: Pursuant to Advertisement No. 3/2014 dated 22.07.2014 for Assistant Engineer (Civil) on contract basis, the petitioners cleared the screening test and appeared for the interview on 28/29.07.2015, but were not recommended. Learning via RTI that the 100-mark interview had no separate break-up, they sought to quash the interview process and have it re-conducted.
- Advertised Criteria & Adherence to Rules: The advertisement explicitly stated that a screening test could be used to shortlist candidates and that final selection would rest solely on the 100-mark viva-voce/interview. The Court found that the Commission followed its Rules of Business, the R&P Rules, and the advertised terms without procedural illegality or mala fides.
- Estoppel, Waiver & Precedents: Relying on Om Prakash Shukla, Madan Lal, Chandra Sekharan, Vijay Syal, Dhananjay Malik, Anupal Singh, Tajvir Singh Sodhi ((2023) 17 SCC 147), and Ashu Jethi (Phull), the Court held that candidates who take a calculated chance without demur cannot challenge the selection criteria after an unfavorable outcome. The Court distinguished Ashok Kumar Yadav, Mohinder Sain Garg, D. Sundara Raju, and Dr. (Major) Meeta Sahai on the facts and prior disclosure of criteria.
- Decision: The petition and pending applications were dismissed without any order as to costs.
STPL (Web) 2026 HP 778
Bhaskar Sehgal and Another vs. State of H.P. and Others (D.O.J. 28.10.2026)
Loading Viewer...





